The Bengals accomplished what they normally set out to do on draft day - dredge up enough hope for the striped masses to sell a few jerseys and keep the suckers drunk until September.
It reads great on paper, but that would make this draft no different than any draft since 1991. Andre Smith looks great, until you take into account his suspension prior to the biggest game of his career, his family, agent problems and the worst combine showing in history. Still, the normally workout-warrior centric Bengals took a flier on someone for their skills on the field, which is indefinitely redundant for a slew of reasons.
They always take fliers. There is always a Dennis Weathersby or a Jason Shirley or a guy most teams won’t draft. Organizations historically pick these type of players when they have to, when you search for value because you don’t know what value is. When you don’t have the scouting network necessary to cultivate good picks, you take the inevitable players that drop. It reads great on paper, but these players have a wretched history of never panning out.
Smith fits this bill. The Bengals had their hearts on the guy, even though he would have dropped out of the top 15 if they passed. As usual, Cincinnati is left competing with itself for a player no one else sees as worth the trouble.
Rey Maualuga fits the bill. Looks great on paper, big hitter and finally, that Ray Lewis-type Marvin Lewis has waited half a decade for, that middle linebacker leader who will take this defense by the nose. Or will he? Maualuga had a terribly mixed history at USC. A battery incident, which he has apparently made up for, but a slew of red flags for a defender expected to play at the highest levels in the NFL.
SI’s featured the three USC linebackers as part of its draft package this week. Maualuga was nearly benched and demoted to second string at one point this season. Pete Carroll open dismissed his performance against Oregon State as dreadful.
Maualuga and Smith have all the talent in the world, but take into account the type of coaches it took to cultivate it. Carroll is the college coach of the moment and the ultimate motivator. Nick Saban is the game’s biggest ball-breaker. They still couldn’t get 100-percent of them all the time, even with NFL millions dangling in front of their eyes. What makes you think Marvin Lewis can, especially after the inevitable paycheck comes?
Forgive my refrain from celebrating or pre-ordering my No. 58 jersey. Yes, this could turn out to be a highly touted class, but that is always the case. Reality and potential seldom realize on the shores of the Ohio River.
Until Mike Brown hires a scouting department, I’ll save my compliments and ewws and ahhs for some other team’s draft class. In my opinion, New England and Cleveland judged this draft the best - they traded down multiple times -thereby stating to the world their judgment on a weak crop.
Until Cincinnati gives me cause to feel otherwise, that’s how their class of 2009 sits - a weak crop.